NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Ethan Salas  Best of 2023 Blue Auto /150,  2023 Bowman's Best Baseball Padres
Buy: $205.00 CAD
Michael Harris II  Reel-to-Reel Die Cut Auto  99/150, 2023 Bowman's Best
Buy: $109.99 CAD
2024 Topps Series 1 ( Bo Naylor ) -  Future Stars GOLDEN MIRROR SSP,  GUARDIANS
Buy: $139.99 CAD
2024 Topps Series 1 ( Seiya Suzuki ) Golden Mirror Image Variation SSP Cubs
Buy: $124.99 CAD
2022 1st Bowman Chrome ~ Jaison Chourio ~ Aqua Vapor 060/125 ~ #BCP-174
Buy: $15.99 CAD
1994 Topps Finest #208 Albert Belle NM FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $10.99 CAD
2023 Topps Bowman Sterling Auto Prospect Signature CHASE DeLAUTER Digital
Buy: $15.75 CAD
2022 Bowman Chrome ~ Jake Fox ~ Sparkle Refractor 033/299 ~ #CPA-JF ~ Auto
Buy: $8.99 CAD
Cleveland Indians Wahoo 59ERA  MLB Fitted Baseball Cap Feather Hat Red Navy Blue
Buy: $57.06 CAD
2023 Topps Series 4 1988 RC Auto Rookie Signature BO NAYLOR Digital
Buy: $14.75 CAD
Bo Naylor 2023 Topps Chrome Update Rookie Autograph Blue Refractor /150 PSA 9
Buy: $110.00 CAD
2024 Topps Series 1 - Superstar Blueprint Insert  *** YOU PICK ***
Buy: $4.00 CAD
***2023 Bowman Chrome Prospects #BCP151 Juan Benjamin- CLEVELAND GUARDIANS
Buy: $2.50 CAD
( George Springer ) 2023 Topps Gilded on card Auto 57/75 Yellow Refractor SGC 10
Buy: $199.99 CAD
(7) Joe Carter 1984 Donruss Rookie card RC 1985 Fleer Topps 1986 1992 Blue Jays
Buy: $27.16 CAD
1984 AL ACTIVE CAREER STRIKEOUT LEADERS SUTTON / BLYLEVEN / KOOSMAN #716 NM
Buy: $6.25 CAD
2024 TOPPS JOSE RAMIREZ BLACK PARALLEL #15/73
Buy: $50.00 CAD
1995 Fleer Diamond Tribute Albert Belle #2 Cleveland Guardians (Indians) NM-Mint
Buy: $2.75 CAD
2021 Panini Prizm Baseball #166 Shane Bieber Red White & Blue Prizm Tier II
Buy: $3.99 CAD
Charlie Sheen 2022 Super Keepsake Green Onyx First Ever Gem Patch Relic /50 #164
Buy: $80.00 CAD
🔥MLB Baseball  Cards Mystery Pack - At Least TWO Auto, Mem, #d Or RC Guaranteed
Buy: $14.99 CAD
2023 Topps Pristine Popular Demand Autograph Relic Orange Jose Ramirez /25
Buy: $89.99 CAD
1994 Topps Finest Albert Belle #208 Cleveland Indians NM FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $3.00 CAD
2017 TOPPS FRANCISCO LINDOR LOGO PATCH J.ROBINSON 70th ANNIVERSARY-AUTO #3/10
Buy: $150.00 CAD
2023 Topps Chrome RC Auto Rookie Signature BO NAYLOR Digital
Buy: $15.75 CAD
Cleveland Indians Wahoo 59ERA Fitted MLB Baseball Cap Feather Hat Black White
Buy: $51.62 CAD
1992 Upper Deck #5 Jim Thome Cleveland Indians Star Rookie RC Baseball (C)
Buy: $2.73 CAD
2023 BOWMAN CHROME JUAN BENJAMIN PROSPECTS-PURPLE SHIMMER PSA 10 GEM MT
Buy: $40.00 CAD
2020 Bowman Yu Chang CHROME SPANNING THE GLOBE MOJO REF #STG-YC  INDIANS RC
Buy: $6.50 CAD
Cleveland Indians Chief Wahoo Jersey Sleeve Official MLB Logo Patch
Buy: $26.08 CAD
1996 Topps Chrome Albert Belle #86 STAR POWER
Buy: $5.75 CAD
Jose Ramirez Pristine Black 1/1 Encased Auto
Buy: $750.00 CAD
1995 Fleer Headliner Albert Belle #2 Cleveland Guardians (Indians) NM-Mint
Buy: $3.00 CAD
1992 Donruss Kenny Lofton Rated Rookie RC Baseball Card # 5 NM+ FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $3.99 CAD
2023 Topps Chrome Tyler Freeman #RA-TF Rookie Auto Guardians - Free Shipping
Buy: $8.49 CAD
2024 Topps Series 1 Bo Naylor Future Stars Silver Foil # 191 Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $5.50 CAD
1954 Topps Al Rosen #15 - Cleveland Indians  FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $14.99 CAD
2022 1st Bowman Chrome ~ Jaison Chourio ~ Shimmer Refractor ~ #BCP-174
Buy: $12.99 CAD
New MLB Cleveland Guardians old time jersey style midweight cotton hoody men XXL
Buy: $97.82 CAD
1999 Fleer Brilliants Baseball Roberto Alomar  Card #121B. Card Is MINT!!
Buy: $6.50 CAD
Jose Ramirez 2023 Topps Chrome Titans  Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $2.99 CAD
2023 Topps Holiday Relics #RC-AG Andres Gimenez
Buy: $2.75 CAD
2011 Topps Bob Feller LEATHER NAMEPLATE Cleveland Indians
Buy: $14.95 CAD
BRANDON DAVIS 2023 Topps baseball series 2 ROOKIE RC DETROIT GARAGE SALE PRICES
Buy: $1.99 CAD
1935 DIAMOND STARS  BASEBALL #8-JOE VOSMIK-PSA 4.5 VG/EX+ 24034376-FREE SHIP WW
Buy: $270.00 CAD
1996 Topps Stadium Club Albert Belle Baseball Card Cleveland Indians #297
Buy: $4.00 CAD
2022 Bowman Draft Chrome Black & White Ray Wave Jhonkensy Noel #BDC-60
Buy: $2.99 CAD
Mark Clark 1993 Upper Deck Series 2 #629 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $2.00 CAD
Felix Fermin 1993 Upper Deck Series 2 #615 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $2.00 CAD
Junior Ortiz 1993 Upper Deck Series 2 #603 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $2.25 CAD
2021 Gabriel Rodriguez Bowman Chrome Prospects GOLD shimmer /50 SGC 10
Buy: $44.99 CAD
1988 TOPPS BIG JOE CARTER CLEVELAND INDIANS #71
Buy: $4.50 CAD
2020 Topps Archives ARISTIDES AQUINO #6 Rookie Card 1955
Buy: $3.00 CAD
1997 Topps Chrome MLB Card #117 Kenny Lofton Cleveland Indians. Card Is MINT!!
Buy: $4.50 CAD
2019 Jake Bauers Rookie Topps Chrome Cleveland Indians # 71
Buy: $2.49 CAD
2020 Topps Gallery AARON CIVALE #56 Rookie Card
Buy: $5.00 CAD
2022 Topps ERNIE CLEMENT #71 Rookie Card
Buy: $3.00 CAD
2022 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary Steven Kwan RC Auto Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $27.11 CAD
2020 Topps SHANE BIEBER major League Material 27/50 (Auto / Material) #MJMA-SB
Buy: $125.00 CAD
1992 DONRUSS RATED ROOKIES # 98  MANNY RAMIREZ ROOKIE. Sharp Corners/Edges. Mint
Buy: $4.50 CAD
2021 Topps Finest SHANE BIEBER 97FM-SB Masters
Buy: $4.00 CAD
Jose Ramirez 2023 Topps Chrome Refractor 35th Anniversary  Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $1.99 CAD
2021 Topps Chrome Andres Gimenez Rookie RC🔥 #88 Cleveland Guardians Mint
Buy: $4.49 CAD
2021 Donruss Optic Pink Prizm #148 Jose Ramirez Cleveland Indians Baseball Card
Buy: $10.00 CAD
1964 Topps Indians Rookie Stars Tommy John
Buy: $19.99 CAD
1992 Fleer JIM THOME #125 Rookie Card
Buy: $3.50 CAD
2022 Topps Chrome Platinum Gabriel Arias Blue Toile Refractor 193/199
Buy: $3.00 CAD
2019 Jake Bauers Rookie Bowman Chrome Cleveland Indians # 3
Buy: $2.49 CAD
Steven Kwan 2022 Topps Update  Rookie RC  #US261 Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $3.99 CAD
DIGITAL 23 Topps Bunt Update TANNER BIBEE RC Legendary Orange Signature #/25
$6.79 CAD (0 bids)
CLIFF LEE 2006 UPPER DECK INKREDIBLE SIGNATURE AUTOGRAPH AUTO #I-CL CLEVELAND
Buy: $35.00 CAD
(5) Jim Thome 1991 Bowman Upper Deck Rookie card RC 1992 Score Fleer Topps HOF
Buy: $20.36 CAD
Steven Kwan 2023 Topps Series One  Rookie Cup Silver Foil #116 Guardians
Buy: $1.79 CAD
(5) Julio Franco 1983 Topps Donruss Rookie card RC 1985 1987 Fleer 1990 Rangers
Buy: $13.57 CAD
1988 Panini Baseball Greg Swindell Sticker 70 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $2.95 CAD
1996 Upper Deck Eddie Murray Baseball Card Cleveland Indians #105. Mint!
Buy: $3.50 CAD
Tanner Bibee 2023 Topps Chrome Update Rookie Debut RC Prism  Refractor #usc94
Buy: $4.99 CAD
1997 Ultra Golden Prospects #6 Brian Giles Indians. Sharp Edges/Corners, MINT!!
Buy: $4.58 CAD
2013 Topps Gold 426 Vinnie Pestano Cleveland Indians Baseball Card
Buy: $1.48 CAD
2023 Panini Chronicles Classics Baseball George Valera 19
Buy: $1.08 CAD
2021 Panini Mosaic Prizm Silver #188 Jose Ramirez Cleveland Indians Baseball
Buy: $10.00 CAD
2024 TOPPS SERIES 1 EASTER HOLIDAY FOIL Logan Allen #339
Buy: $10.00 CAD
Aaron Civale 2023 Topps Series 2 Blue Foil #/999
Buy: $4.99 CAD
97-98 Fleer Decade Of Excellence Matt Williams #12 SF Giants Clevland Indians
Buy: $5.00 CAD
2021 Donruss Optic Andres Gimenez RC  Rated Rookie  #53
Buy: $2.99 CAD
1995 Fleer Headliner Kenny Lofton #12 Cleveland/Guardians Indians NM-Mint
Buy: $2.65 CAD
1990 Leaf Candy Maldonado MVP Insert Cleveland Guardians MLB Baseball Card #391
Buy: $2.99 CAD
1996 Manny Ramirez Upper Deck #188 Global Impact Insert
Buy: $4.00 CAD
1998 Pacific Aurora Pennant Fever Manny Ramirez #38 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $4.75 CAD
Aaron Civale Rookie 2020 Topps Bowman Chrome #36 Indians MLB Baseball Card
Buy: $3.03 CAD
1984 Donruss JOE CARTER #616
Buy: $5.00 CAD
2023 Topps Holiday Jose Ramirez Ornament Card MLBDC-5 Cleveland Guardians
Buy: $2.99 CAD
1984 OPC O-Pee-Chee Baseball Ron Hassey #308 Cleveland Indians NM/MT
Buy: $1.99 CAD
1990 Leaf Candy Maldonado MVP Insert # 391 Cleveland Guardians Baseball Card
Buy: $2.49 CAD
2022 Topps Chrome Platinum Franmil Reyes Autograph
Buy: $12.00 CAD
1964 Topps #172 Cleveland Indians
Buy: $6.99 CAD
1996 Pacific Baseball #307 Albert Belle. Card Is MINT!
Buy: $4.50 CAD
2023 Topps Inception #59 Shane Bieber
Buy: $5.50 CAD
Shane Bieber Topps card Japan Edition 2022 #91 42/99 Major League Baseball
Buy: $27.16 CAD
Topps Fire MLB Baseball Cards Factory Sealed Collector Hobby Box 2021 20 Packs
Buy: $171.22 CAD